The Flyer: A Hot Mess Of Weather Forecasting
“I hate to call it a worst case scenario,” wrote the internet meteorologist, “but this is a worst case scenario.
The week just gone was a hot mess of weather forecasting. A category 5 farce when a Tasman Low deepened off the NSW coast and the media couldn’t contain themselves.
When low pressure systems deepen rapidly they undergo what’s called ‘cyclogenesis’ which is a mix of two Greek words - ‘kyklo’ for circle and ‘genesis’ for creation.
Cyclones also undergo cyclogenesis, yet the low that formed off the NSW coast this week was not a cyclone as we know it.
However, that didn’t stop journalists running with the term. No surprise as it’s loaded with the kind of feelings media people secretly enjoy: drama, anguish, danger.
Worse was when they learned the ‘cyclone’ had deepened fast enough to ‘bomb’.
Let’s pause for a moment. Media people weren’t fabricating here, a low can deepen so quickly it crosses a threshold where weather people say they ‘bomb’. It’s a faintly ridiculous term, created in the land of battleground states and supermarkets, but it’s become accepted in the world of weather.
So that’s why, in the eastern states at least, ‘bomb cyclone’ ran in so many headlines, plus other terms such as ‘bombogenesis’, which conjured both a Biblical sense of awe and of great destruction.
No wonder it got air-time.
Once it found its way to social media, where admins aren’t restricted by things like regulations or press standards, the bomb cyclone went viral - first explosive, then destructive, and now it was infectious too.
Facebook forecasters filled the Attention Economy with anxiety-inducing content. ‘The biggest’, ‘the strongest’, ‘the scariest’.
Somewhere in the maelstrom a lone voice spoke out:
"We don’t really use the term bomb cyclone,” said Jonathon How from the Bureau of Meteorology. “We just talk about a low-pressure system deepening very quickly because ‘bomb’ can create a little bit more panic and sounds a little bit more scary than what it actually is."
It was a big system, no doubt about it, but no lives were lost, no houses either, the wind blew hard on Tuesday and Wednesday, as it does every time an East Coast Low forms. Which, despite associated headlines, happens roughly once a year. The outlet that said we hadn’t had an ECL “in three years” ran ECL headlines in 2023 and 2024.
“I don’t know why everyone’s making a big deal out of it now,” said a caller to ABC Illawarra, a postman by employment. “Back in the day people would just yell at me for getting their letters wet.”
Which, to be fair, is a postie’s worst case scenario.
- Stu
The Flyer is Swellnet's weekend newsletter.
Online Pirates And Internet Ghosts
In 1990, Bruce Raymond, CEO of Quiksilver, raided a Bali warehouse full of counterfeit Quik product, drove to Uluwatu, and made a bonfire of the pirated fabrics.
Meanwhile, in 2025 counterfeiters inhabit the digital realm and are harder to catch. Read More >
Jack McCoy Paddle Out Today
All the details are in the image.
Finals Wrap: Rio Pro 2025
It's my job to make this contest recap by Steve sound exciting, but it's late on Friday arvo, the comp finished days ago, and it was largely forgettable.
Not Steve's writing though, that was good. Read More >
Watch: Kipp Caddy // Firing Cape Solander
"It's a day by day thing," says Kipp Caddy about his approach to big Cape Solander. "Some days I'll grab the rope, some days I'm up for the challenge."
This vid, made with good mate Cameron Staunton, shows Kipp and co. going headlong on a classic autumn day at the Cape. Read More >
Watch: Filipe Toledo // Raíz y Sal
Watch the world's fastest surfer in slow mo. Read More >
Comments
This is exactly what I felt and thought at the time - hyped hysteria, overdramatic.
It was supposed to be targeted at where I live Mind North Coast, and we had some heavy rain and great surf, but it was not as bad as a month ago.
I don't know if you saw the ABC.net.au article turning itself inside and out that it was not a rain bomb or bomb cyclone and people should stop calling it one or the other.
It was typical of the ABC drama cycling started with Covid and its gotten worse. Then it influences channel 9/Fairfax which impacts the others
Journalism really needs to be brought back to old school or simply forced to be real and factual, as the ABC is supposed to be unbiased and higher brow... FFS
The trotted out the Wamberal erosion same as I think 2021? Same people etc
The weather ain't changing - the sand on the beach here changes fast in just day and has done for millennia!
Suddenly its two steps less to walk up then its down to the base rock
I keep trying to forgive them but they are guided by the Bureau of Manure and they seem from the oustide to be clueless with an agenda.
bring a south swell sand goes one way bring in north swell sand goes the other way... any questions. serious as people who know that a wedge makes a crazy triple bowl how much more do we need to be told.
In the northern Hemi they've been giving Atlantic winter storms names for a while now, hope we don't get to that level.
Personally I particularly like the use of the term "wild weather".
Never gets old, impossible to overuse and by gum, the alliteration just gives me the warm and fuzzies.
I love it when Swellnet Stu takes the meteorolical high ground
?si=ugM1lTN7Ee0BZSaTHey Youse ass trumpets
j bay forcast looks good for the start