Trouble Shooter // The Five Fin Surfboard
G'Day Murray,
Are five fin set ups, where your board can be a Thruster or quad fin, worth getting? I can remember when they first started coming out some magazine commenters said they were a compromise of both designs and not worth getting. The message was that you've got to tell the shaper to make the board one fin set up or the other.
Since then they've become really popular, so what gives with five fin set ups?
Yours in trouble,
Neville Beats Buddha

Hey Neville,
Good question and one that is never asked, although it should be.
Historically, they began appearing in the early 2000s when surfers were still unsure of the quad's virtues so dropping five plugs in seemed like less risk - if four fins don't work then switch to three!
In my humble opinion the five fin set up is nothing but a bet each way sanctioned by the retailers who are loathe to lose a sale. The fact is that Thrusters come from the centre fin family and quads are essentially from the twin fin family, which are totally opposites.
So yes, they are a compromise thwarting the designer from really putting his heart into one design or the other. Still, there are many surfers out there, particularly the older crew, that are not pushing the extremes and are happy to surf in 'either/or' mode - so I think they do have their place.

Mostly it's a planshape argument that separates the two modes. There are other concerns as well, which I will explain later, but generally a Thruster is surfed off the tail while tending to the centre fin, whereas a quad is surfed further forward where a wider nose can not only be tolerated but necessary.
One thing I have to say from the onset is that, on most of the five-fin boards I see in the shops, all the fin's positions are in the correct place for each mode. It only gets more difficult as the board gets longer, particularly if the tail stays wide where the centre fin cannot follow the quads which need to go further forward as a set in order to have sway over a nose further away.
The Thruster is a 'pivot and drive' action whereas the quad is just a full-on driving sled that lacks the pivot but delivers superior speed and face hold. Is it any wonder that Kelly won all those Pipe Masters trophies when Backdoor was on and he was smart enough to quad up, sit high, and come out. A Thruster couldn't sit that high or allow a surfer to set the rail mid-face after the takeoff - no bottom turn.
A quad fin, almost like a twinny, can suffer a wider nose because you don't need to nurse the centre fin by surfing off the tail. It therefore allows you to operate the board from a more forward position meaning you can bust out of the gates from the get go, not to mention they will slip into the wave much earlier because they paddle in better.
They probably don't need as much rocker either since their east/west is merely a tilt from rail to rail which is pretty easy with speed.
If you ride quads and see a five-fin set up with those features then it passes the first test.
Thrusters are still the choice of most competitive surfers where the aim is to slam vertically off the bottom to launch the air reverse they're all brainwashed into believing is the hallmark of a truly great surfer. To be fair, there's a good reason they've been around for so long and it is a delight to see how far John John can push them if that turn at Margarets can be believed, but please do not think you can do the same because he's a one-off!
Fundamentally, quads like barrels and long, almost unmakeable, walls because of their easy-to-access speed. You don’t have to work for it and due to their extra forward width, they paddle in better.
It's this facet that's the big quandary when designing either/or. A Thruster will always feel front heavy with a wider nose, while a quad will lose drive if you pull the nose in and add the rocker that Thrusters need.
So let's just understand that the five fin era was driven by retailers who were just too focused on the bottom line!
However, five fin boards also helped popularise the quad - many surfers took a chance on a five fin set up and realised they like quads.
Thankfully we're now approaching a period where punters are realising they can't have everything built into just one board, so they're happy to let designers be more specific with three or four fins and free to make the best Thruster or quad they know they can!
- Muzz
Visit Pipedream Surfboards online. Muzz, as keen-eyed readers will notice, also has the odd each way bet, however if you really want a shaper to put their heart into a board then give him a call.
PS: 'Trouble Shooter' is a new column where shaper Murray Bourton answers all your surfboard related questions. If you're got a burning question and didn't know who to ask then jot it below or send to stuart@swellnet.com. Muzz will be back in a week or so.
Comments
Fantastic read.
Murray you have put into really simple language something I have been sort of on the cusp of understanding but not really getting.
It all makes sense now.
I can stop thinking now.
(Until I choose some fins)
I have always tried to keep it simple since hydro dynamics is a complicated thing particularly with all different locations and skill levels and body sizes. I must say the literage ting has surely got out of hand since it was introduced in all cad designs. A personal conversation speaks volumes when it comes to customizing models for customers and sadly with this new gen they seem incapable of speaking verbaly on the blower and simply want to text their way through the complete process, man I could write a friken novel in order to get one of these customers over the line and still get it wrong!
Wow, not at all the answer I was expecting. Thought for sure it'd be fin position though it makes sense when thinking about my best thrusters and quads.
Fantastic explanation muzza!
I've been on a quad since the mid 80s
90 I drifted to the thruster back to quads for the last couple of decades.
Some times if I surf a thruster, it feels like I have an e brake on my board
Lol
I wasn't expecting to see that when I logged on. You've made my morning, Murray!
It makes sense why 5 fin boards are popular, but then why do it if you're a devoted 3 or 4 fin surfer?
"...most competitive surfers where the aim is to slam vertically off the bottom to launch the air reverse they're all brainwashed into believing is the hallmark of a truly great surfer." Amen to that.
Lots of food for thought in that answer. Thanks.
Good question and answer.
I've got one of the 5 fin box boards but only ever seem to use it as a thruster.
Do people ever use them with 5 fins?
Or is 5 fins a guaranteed bog set-up creating a less than ideal anti-best of both worlds lots of drag performance outcome?
I'd probably try it, but means I'd have to buy a couple more fins...
Yeah you and everybody else Westo. They all just surf to their safety knowing how a thruster goes and rarely quad up. The only functional way to use the centre fin box when in quad mode is to use a very small Darcy keel where you will find a little sense of centre to give you a tad more ping and hold in bigger waves. This small keel can also act as a trainer for those trying to convert from thruster to quads.
Wow
I guess I better come clean.
Huge fan of the 5 fin set-up.
Love tinkering with boards as quads and thrusters- especially small wave boards.
Quads on your backhand at points- so much effortless speed.
Thrusters in bowly waves on forehand or whatever.
Never found a board where it was a disadvantage.
Would find it difficult to get a board without the 5 fin set-up.
If it's good enough for an 11 time World Champ it's good enough for me.
Lol, swellnet confesion booth !
KS owns FW and Endorfin, and both sell 5 fin options. According to AM and Greg W Kelly's thruster and quad outlines were different though I don't think that applied to his Hawaiian quiver.
FR agree, I like playing around with fin setups.
One argument I've heard is that the 5-fin setup can unnecessarily stiffen up the tail of the board. Probably more of an issue with Futures and FCS2, don't think the little FCS1 plugs would cause too many issues there. Sounds plausible to me, what do you (or Murray) reckon about that?
Yeah that has always been a concern for me, full well knowing that even though tail flex is hard to read if it is taken away you will know about it that's for sure ! Personally I do not encourage future boxes with 5 fin designs for fear of stiffening up tail flex. Less of an evil I think is Fcs2 when applying 5 boxes because they are not quite as long and do not have straight sides which I think would help minimize that stiffness a tad. I would not argue that with just quads only futures should not be used. Certainly I believe that in thrusters futures are by far the best or the closest feel to set fins of old. With a future fin the whole base of the fin fits end to end in the box giving the best base anchor so minimizing any base lean through turns so all the pressure gets loaded up on the tip where it is meant to be.
Thanks for the reply Murray, appreciate it, and the insights!
Same here FR, on the how and why with conditions.
To Mr B's point about quads working better with a lower rocker, I started making most of my boards that way in the late nineties (thrusters).
A chap above questioned whether five fins ever work - something I borrowed from KS, is using a knubster when there is more size/power, it's really surprising, the increase in hold and drive.
As with all things in surfing, it's whatever floats your boat.
Maybe you should mover to the front yard Mr Backyard coz you a dead right on the nubster option and how it helps. One point I might make is that with quads they will run better if flatter and will not be stiffened up with this option, but adding more rocker to them especially in power is a smart option as well. They are so fast that slowing them down with added rocker for more face vert in power they will still burn more rubber than a thruster every other day!
I ride quads and a few times have tried certain boards in certain conditions as a thruster but usually revert back to quad set up . In long 4-5 ft walls that aren’t hollow I like the 2+ 1 set up . I have a puddle jumper HP round which I ride as a quad with a nubster as the 5th fin , gives me a bit more stability when waves get overhead + as the tail is fairly wide . So the 5 fin boxes have a wide variety I find but also like dedicated quad set ups in longer boards . I doubt someone of my ability is affected by having a fifth box that is open and may affect the tail in some small way . I prefer the look of that clean tail bottom however, as opposed to a fin box that’s not being used on larger boards . Resale value is helped I believe by having a 5 fin option .
macca's illustration put me in mind of this old late show clip
ha, that looks fucking unreal if the placements are as thought through and precision as they appear to be.. (be cool to see @Westof try cram 9 fins into it ; )
I think it was an experiment by Murray and Brooko to find a fin placement that would work for Brooko's quads in the early 2000's
I think you're right @david 24, I remember that... I think!
I can also recall that may have been a bit of concern that it was susceptible to creasing between that back cluster and the front fins?
Anyway......
Go the Westo....he would be leaving more wake than Donald Campbell at Lake Eyre !
If Muz puts a longer centre box in it could be set up as a Claw. The 6th mode ;-)
I agree with you Muzz about the planshapes, but not about the fin positions. But it's just my personal preference. I've ridden quads for 20 or more years and found the McKee style set up - fixed ratio between the distance front fins are apart and rear fins are apart,
For me that puts the rear fins closer to the stringer than most shop boards I see,
Keep up the good work.
Prefer the McKee placement too.
Some 5 fin set-ups have the stringer-centric placement.
Yeah Bruce through working with Tommy Carrol in France was the one responsible for the acceptance of modern day quad design. I was making them back in the early 80 's and was placing the quad trailers to close to the rail and Bruce told me to set the 2" in from the rail and the rest is history. The cluster is another story and certainly an important component in back foot positioning.
Nice writeup Murray
When I 1st started making boards I used the 5 box setup in case my rails were rubbish and wouldn't hold on a hard bottom turn in thruster mode... change to quad setup all good :)
Since have combined quads with channels still getting the speed plus allows the board to turn a little better.
Enjoy this topic, I regularly swap between a quad and thruster setup in my go to all-rounder style board with a round tail. For me the decision depends on the type of turn that will suit the wave/conditions I'm looking at. For speed & tight arcs outside the pocket on small - medium smooth flatter waves I'd slip in the quads. If the wave has some crumble, bit of bump, the thruster is gunna work better in the lip. If the wave face is cupped out the thruster will pivot/ jam/ release better in a tight pocket. So Im a fan of the extra fin option in one board.
What about ditching the rear fins altogether and surfing as a twinnie. Muzza and man says they follow that path anyway so get a three in one board!
No twins over here ...
Hawaii?
In my quiver.... @ goofy lol
Hey Memlasurf the only problem with that idea is the twin fin position up from the tail is less distance than the front fins on a quad or indeed a thruster.
Yeah, I know, just stirring the pot. Got a great Twin from Bean down here with the new MF twin set and a little stabilizer, great board, a real 6' all rounder for an aging never been. Works in Indo, Fiji, and back on the peninsula.
Troy Brooks round tail quad/mach 2 was a revelation for me from the first wave.
Didn't feel like I needed to change anything in my surfing from thrusters but it just did it all better and faster with no pumps.
i just cannot do thrusters anymore constantly feel like i'm dragging a plastic bag behind me and oddly thrusters feel to loose after years of quads and twins my stance and style has adjusted.
Thrusters have there place , ......in someone else's quiver, in the back shed or waves over 4 feet that are super hollow and short
Don't trust her if she's a thruster! in saying that i love a twin trailer which i guess is a thruster.
Good stuff, Murray and Swellnet.
Ordered a 6'6 Reef Swallow from Murray almost 10 years ago, and I was already a quad guy. "I'll just widen the tail a little, if you're gonna ride it mostly as a quad..."
Turns out the board was magic as a quad and as a thruster, and it still is. It's so finely foiled, and so sensitive, and it sometimes scares my a bit just looking at it and holding it under the arm. But it's easily among the best boards I've had. Thank you!
I reckon 5-fin plugs are great up to 7'4 or 7'6, then you wanna go either or.
Muzz you said a few times when I've talked to you about quads , quads work best on a round tail board because you can't tell where the tail is . Always wanted to ask you exactly what you mean ?
What I meant Shaun was that quads struggle rotating vertical because they are so klingy ,that is to say they bight the face like a pit bull that's why they are so good in barrels. This comes at a cost when trying to pivot off the bottom. A thruster is a stall and swing motion off the bottom and this sets up for more vert, however a quad just wants to grip to the face and go like a cut cat. Using a round tail on a quad allows it to rotate more freely say like a ball and socket joint where your trailer follow your car around a corner without argument if you get my drift..? Of course it will still never be a pivotal as a thruster. Get my drift now Shaun?
Copy Muzz got it thanks for the reply
Talking about the thruster without mentioning Simon Anderson or the quad particularly at pipeline without mentioning Glenn Winton ... And the latter has been experimenting with multiple fins including five and more for the last 15 years
Jack Knight, who I think shaped for Glenn, first pitched his quads to me circa 2009
I do love the 5 fin setup for my performance board. I'll usually run it as a thruster, but when my local slab turns on and I want more hold or the waves are a little weaker and I need more effortless speed, I love being able to chuck in the quads.
The thing is quads can be twin fin based by being pushed onto the rail such as in the case of split keel set ups or very thruster like with them pushed close to the stringer so it’s not as simple as that either. Based on Murray’s logic the 5 fin set up would work best with the back fins closer to the stringer which I agree with too.
Perfect explanation .
Great article, thanks. I would probably have stuck with thrusters except that the 5 fin setup let me experiment. Now I basically always surf my favourite board as a quad but it does have a wide nose and little rocker so your explanation makes a lot of sense.
This is awesome content and I'm stoked on this series Muz and Swellnet! More please, we need all the questions answered. Now, where did I see that Lightning Bolt shaped by MB for sale again.......
Am only a phone call away Mr Slippery soap 0421 385 692
Great article. Love listening to Muzz's professor type ramblings - and that's a compliment. Had a few of his boards back in the day and they were all good, all thrusters, all sd concaves except one.
Got a reverse vee from the shop at Main Beach and it was horrible. Took it back to trade and they did a swap for one of Skye's boards when he was kinda starting out and it turned out to be one of the best boards I've ever had.
Seems he was taught well!
Yeah Arnold the reverse vee concept needs power and speed to do its thing. If you are not going fast enough the straighter rail rocker caused by lifting the rail through the centre to create the vee - will catch!
Got a PipeDreams channel bottom from Benny Kings second hand board shop down near Cheeky Monkeys.
Thing was a blade but I got some of the best waves of my life on it when the Superbank was starting and was just white line fever from Snapper to Spot X.
GR8 article MB & SN - I love to contemplate these issues. FTR - I'm pretty much always quad these days. Unless it's a pure pivot wave and I can be bothered changing my fins.
Hydrophilic
https://www.gumtree.com.au/web/listing/surfing/1338673305
There's really is something wonderful when shapers of such skill and longevity provide their wisdom. It's why when you get a board off them you go, "do what you think will work for me!" And step away.
Hey clif, what is so sad today is that conversations leading to custom surfboards are so far and few between simply because young surfers or indeed the young public in general fear conversation and just want to hide behind a keyboard and fire away, but refuse to pick up a phone...fuck we are not royalty, we just shape surfboards and could shape better ones for you with a decent conversation ! Add to that there are so many hard core board shops around these day since the demise of surf rag that have hundreds of stock boards to choose from and some wiz kid in there whose job it is to convince you this board is better than that one, but really he knows fuck all. They say now that custom orders are about 20% of all surfboard sales and the rest is off the rack. Not sure what that means, but to me it seems our wisdom is perhaps a little overlooked.
Would be good to get your in-depth analysis on your Twinza muzz, I have 2 of them, best boards I ever had!
Hey Crustie, I have a very in depth description of this model as a swallow tail early in their development on my bourtonshapes.com web site if you have not already read it. I am not sure it is my place to use this forum to market my boards so directly but I do agree with you it is the best surfboard ever I have designed in my life. To see them make a comeback of late is reassuring albeit the designs on the market now are really nothing like my Twinzaa.
Hi Muzza , with the 5 fin set up , is the twin fin 2 + 1 ok in your opinion or are they better placed in a dedicated twin fin position with box for trailer or nubster ?
Hey Supafreak I am not sure what model you are referring to, if indeed it is even one of mine..?
High Muz , yeah not one of your boards . Its a lost mayhem puddle jumper HP round tail that I normally ride as a quad. It’s my groveler which when waves aren’t hollow but more wall like , I ride it with MF 2+1 fins . My question was with the 5 fin configuration , normally a twin fin would be set further back so how do you see the 2+ 1 going in that set up .
Hey Supafreak a 2+1 set up cannot be functionally configured from a normal 5 fin set up. For one the rear centre fin is too far back and not adjustable as it needs to be for an alpha centre fin which needs to be in a fin box so it can be moved further forward. I do have a model called the Gentleman which has a quad set up and a 8" fin box whereas all the fins are strategically positioned where the board can be surfed as a 2+1 or a quad. Donald Takayama also had this idea way back.
Thanks for replying Muz and it’s very interesting as the board does go unreal in certain waves with the 2 + 1 MFs . I found in hollow waves it was shit and was wondering if the fin box placements were the problem .
I think I am still a little confused...but oh well Ken ?
No not Ken , Mark R . I did ride your boards for about 30 years . When I say 2+1 , I’m not referring to a large fin with 2 trailers, I’m talking about twin fins with a single trailer , in this case the Mick Fanning FCS 2 + 1 .
Now I get it Mark, yes it is the centre box placement. When they set up a five fin configuration it is to be ridden as a thruster or quad and everything works okay in either mode but with a big Twin fin and a small trailor set up the centre fin has to be further forward than what a normal thruster centre fin would be which are normally about 3 /1/2" from the tail. If the centre fin in your case is needed for a little more support but not to mimic the action of a normal sized thruster centre fin then its distance from the tail needs to be moved closer to the big alphas so when doing a bottom turn you are under no illusion that you can rely on that centre fin holding when you are about to punch off the bottom. So what I am saying, that with normal 5 finners you buy, that centre fin is too far back for a nubster size trailor .
Cheers Murray , got there in the end, all the best for Xmas & new year, would be great to see you at that left in mentawai that Greg V goes to , get onto him, you would love it .
Yeah I am just waiting for him to build his wig wam there. I told him to paint my bedroom sky blue so it is the same colour as my shaping bay. Ha Ha Best wishes to you too mate , have a good one !
Would Power Base Quad Box in the Rear give Enough Adjustment...Nearly an Inch ?
Yep the power base system give you about 3/4" movement which is not enough but will make a difference.
If it’s futures, the AMT+1 trailer is a little further forward.
I’ve seen other ones set forward on the single tab but can’t remember where.
Udo, what do you recon those fin measurements are?
No idea but Futures Boxes are 5 7/8 Long - Im Sure Muzz would Share if Asked.
5 7/8 ....ah of course, slaps forehead cheers