Topped and tailed by quality overhead surf with the rest of the day mostly torn up by persistent devil winds and a long low tide slump, the New Zealand Pro marched through Round 2 for Men and Women.
The sun was shining and people whipped out to watch live, but apart from a few key heats it was an underwhelming affair with pro surfing and pro surfers highlighting some bizarre paradoxes about the sport.

Manu lineup (WSL/Sloane)
Paradox one. Competition surfing is supposed to represent the apex of the sport/artform but so often we see surfers unable to show their full potential. In what other sport does competition routinely bring out a worse version of an athlete?
Watching the recent Red Bull movie about women's surfing is a mind blowing affair. But almost halfway through the year, what percentage of the surfing we know she can do has Erin Brooks been able to bring into competition? 10, 20, 40%. No way it’s 50%.
Imagine Usain Bolt running like a cheetah and then when the gun goes he runs 100 metres in 20 seconds. Twice as slow as we know he can run. State of Origin and Nathan Cleary can only kick the ball half as far as a regular game. Conditions no doubt have been unfavourable for Brooks, but that is part of the structural issue: competition at the elite level is stymying their performances.

Cole (WSL/Estrada)
Another example: Jordy Smith tearing huge chunks out of the Northern Rivers recently showing he is still the premier power surfer on the planet. What percentage of Jordy Smith’s best surfing have we seen so far this year on tour? 10%? If that…
Same goes Caity Simmers and Tya Zebrowski. They gotta find a way to get these guys and gals into better waves, more often. It can’t be right to have a tour and a contest format that so consistently fails to extract, or allow, the best surfing performances from surfers. We’ll get to paradox two in a minute.
Talk to anyone on the street and the word is a Brazilian goofyfoot will win this contest. No-one would quibble with that assertion after the performances of Medina day one, or Italo and Yago this morning. If we get a blast of swell to finish - anything head high or above - Yago should go in hot favourite. The rail game is deeper, repertoire more varied, and the air game the most dependable and lofty on tour. A win here and the Dora title defence is sailing on a fast downwind run.

Yago (WSL/Estrada)
All the young dudes on Tour are gym junkies. Muscle matters more than ever. That was one of the great advantages of having boots on the ground on the Gold Coast - being able to size up the competitors as athletic specimens. Of the men on tour, Joel Vaughan is one of the slightest. He still looks like a slim-hipped teenager and not at all like a Bulgarian weightlifter as does Kauli Vaast, or even with a wombat arse on him like Toledo. I saw that lack of horsepower as the primary reason he sits way back down in the field at 22nd place, and why he narrowly lost to Kanoa Igarashi. The heat hinged on a final exchange, won by Vaughan, but with enough pure power and spray shifted by Igarashi that he was able to bridge the deficit and take the heat.
That exchange should be mandatory viewing for Vaughan and his coaching team. He was beaten, arguably by worse surfing, but executed with more power.

Joel (WSL/Sloane)
Watch any of the recent JS team videos and you’ll see new member Jack Robinson getting compliments for the size of the hams - tribute to the gym work he’s put in post-knee surgery. Something is not quite translating though between the theoretical force production and the power in the turns for Jack. At times, his turns still look weak and tinny.
In his heat with Vaast today, the finest of the day based on wave quality and surfing, what his turns lacked in power they made up for in placement and variety. He forced Vaast into needing an excellent score and the Tahitian responded with the ride of the heat. A brutally-hacked set wave garnered a 9, but the answer back from Robinson, a close to excellent ride, sealed the heat for the West Australian as the two men waited onshore.

Jack (WSL/Sloane)
By the time the women hit the water a mean devil wind was washing across the bay. The type of wind that ruins a session, makes doing a clean turn almost impossible. A wind that favoured, to be honest, the more athletic and the gym junkies on the women's tour. Not all are trainers, like the men. There are those who spend almost as much time in the gym as they do in the water, Erin Brooks, Sawyer Lindblad, Alyssa Spencer to name a few. Then there are the ‘nattys’, like Caity Simmers and Steph Gilmore to whom the word gym conjures up the guy who comes and mows the lawn when you are on tour.
Watching some of the women struggle to gain momentum on a fast running, slopey little left running into a stiff devil wind on a tide draining energy out of the swell both highlighted the athletic difference on tour and brought to light the second great paradox of pro surfing - the paradox of equipment.
In all other sports, and most human endeavours, the direction of innovation flows from the elite to the common practitioner. A lot of sports, Formula One and golf, to name two off the top of my head, justify much of their existence by this ability to trickle down improvements to the common vehicle or golfer respectively. We benefit, from their R&D, from their testing at the top level under the demands of elite competition.

Isabella (WSL/Sloane)
In surfing, the arrow of innovation goes the other way. Or at least it has since the last great pro surfer innovation, the Thruster. Everything since then, has flowed from the recreational or backyard builders to the pros. Four fins? Apart from a brief dalliance by Glen Winton, they were perfected by Bruce McKee and Nathan Fletcher before Kelly Slater brought them to the tour. All the various fishy, alt-type boards have been worked on obsessively by surfers not on tour.
Somehow, Toledo on Day 1 riding a perfectly bog standard rec surfer design (basically a shrunken version of the MR flyer/swallowtail twin plus a trailer) was heralded as some kind of brave leap into the design universe. And even after it was proven to be a superior tool for the small running lefts we saw surfer after surfer struggling to stay pace with the small, windy lefts.
Please don’t credit pro surfers with any innovations in materials either. On that score they are hopelessly timid and conformist. In 1996, thirty years ago, there were at least two commercial manufacturers in Byron Bay offering full vacuun bagged EPS/composite construction boards. Carbon fibre was perfected as a laminate at least a decade before that by George Greenough and others.
Jason Stevenson in recent videos and today claimed an innovation as a result of pre-season testing was increasing the volume to account for the extra leg power of modern pro surfers. No shit, Sherlock, I thought. Recreational surfers have been increasing volume on anorexic pro boards for over a decade using the theory that volume equals resistance and if you want drive you need something to push against that pushes back with equal force.

Caity (WSL/Estrada)
For me, nothing exemplified both the paradox of performance and the paradox of equipment like Caity Simmers’ heat against Alyssa Spencer. To be fair, the surf had reached its nadir. Gutless, windy lefts struggled to offer any meaningful rides and as soon as Alyssa had hassled Caity out of the opening ride her heart did not look in it. But she offered no meaningful opposition either. The whole town had whipped out. Taxpayers money spent erecting the circus so she could perform and…nothing .
It was an almost quintessential pro surfing moment when pitchman Vaughan Blakey was fizzing with a local businessman about it being like Christmas and all the local businesses cashing in with great joy and exuberance. Meanwhile, a hundred metres seaward, 2024 World Champion Caitlin Simmer sat forlornly with shoulders hunched forwards, back to the ocean, hunched into a mean wind on a 0.0 heat score having caught no waves and showing no signs of intending to.
They don’t…get it. The paradox of performance.
When she did catch a wave, her board looked hopelessly slow and out of sorts on the weak left. Where was the suitable equipment that Toledo so emphatically showed was suitable for the job?

Carissa (WSL/Sloane)
My feed slowed to a crawl and then jammed up entirely as the last heats hit the water. From replays I can see that magic hour up to sunset lived up to its billing as the wind laid down to a zephyr and sets began strafing the point. Carissa rode some magic waves and over-hyped rookie phenom Tya Zebrowski continued her miserable start to the season with a poor performance against Caz Marks.
Female favourite? Head says Sawyer Lindblad, heart says Carissa Moore, who seems blessed by luxuriant set waves every time she hits the lineup. Judging by the fickle way Manu Bay blesses her suitors mana would assume priority over anything.
// STEVE SHEARER
Comments
Good to hear you making valid points about the pros needing to be more versatile and better prepared regards equipment, horses for courses etc. I wish the WSL could be more versatile too regards their contractual arrangements with each Government tourism department on tour. Like for goodness sake, if the forecast looks like being a dud for the entire waiting period, and it’s pumping for three days before the official waiting period, and everyone is there with all the required infrastructure in place, then get rid of the ‘training days’ and run the bloody thing. They could have had this event done and dusted on the opening day, all in pumping waves. Another missed opportunity, how many more? Extend the waiting period to two weeks, half a moon cycle, would seem to be the go.
+1 seahound... +1..!!! can always extend a waiting period out but can't start 3 days in the past...
Yeah, even to have the option start a few days earlier or later to account for chance. Only makes sense to me.
That Carissa/Lakey heat was bizarre. Nothing ridden until the last 10 minutes. Then sets galore.
It was like "should we...?" when the first wave hit at 10 minutes to go. Then Riss showed all of her experience. And then the waves didn't stop. Complete heat wave count in under 10.
There were waves in that first 20mins, just C and L decided hassling for priority was more important than actually surfing
The broadcast is insulting to surfing. Everything is blue skies and how great is this, the town is buzzing with shoppers. The Manu car park is suffocating on commerce, did they even need the dog and p only side show of competition? As a type up, you're being very generous SS.
The wave makes the surfing so boring I cant watch it.
Everyone surfs exactly the same on every wave.
+1 . I can only imagine what a cluster.... Raglan will become after this circus departs .
This place was once on my list of places to surf but the list of negatives is outnumbering
the positives .
Great write up FR one of your best.
So true about pro equipment and how conservative the tour is.
Backside surfing hardly changed in 30 years apart from airs.
Maybe they should go back to running the longboard tour along side it and send out the LBs on the knee high runners.
I guess it all boils down to how the tour is judged and why an Alternative Ripper can't compete on a Fish.
Imagine a triathlon tour where you have 3 heats and you have to ride a LB MIdlength/Alt board and a shortboard. Highest score over 3 heats wins.
Was it Dave Parameter who ride a longboard once in a heat back in the 80s?
Yes to DP ,
Just canoe surfs nowadays
Bizarre
The forecast is so grim, the surfers will be forced to bust out the alt kit. If you're riding CI or Lost it's not like you don't have plenty of grovellers to choose from.
Yeah don't get.
Any thoughts on the forecast? Will they have the balls to go on hold until Sunday/Monday?
Not sure they have much choice.
Renato’s interview sounds like they’re gonna check every morning and would run one or two heats if it’s surfable each day to get the remaining total of heats down.
they will have to whittle it down somewhere along the way.
from the rocks all day, would say that around 50% of the scoring opportunities were missed from poor lineup placement and poor section management, which didn't seem to be obvious or addressed in the online coverage, the present day Raglan Area School Surf Academy and it's alumni were all perplexed that best in the world seem to have no clue where to be, and neither did their coaches, saw plenty of 8 turned into 5s and many many sets missed entirely
I had a feeling that was the case, but I've only been watching online.
If they come back next year, the surfers need someone with local knowledge to coach them. and the Wozzle need a local forecaster.
Ethan and Gabby Bryan employed Matt Scorringe.
Ethan still looked like his wave selection wasn’t optimal.
Matty is from the east coast and hardly surfs manu when he comes over
Yes a friend came back from the comp and said exactly that. So many waves unridden. Carissa and Leakey way out of position, moved in and got plenty. Caz and tya followed them in but the golden hour has sets back on the point. Just shows that the more time out there the better they will get. And even the pros need to learn a new venue. And some people are picking it up much quicker than others.
Yes Eddy so true, I was watching lots from the rocks and couldn't believe how incompetent some of the coaching was for positioning. It's not hard to see that raglan has large tidal changes and that it would change a lot over the day
I guess many recreational boardriders are constantly looking for that board that is going to, in some way, make up for their ability shortfalls.
Pros are generally looking for a more neutral board that isn’t going to get in the way of them expressing their superior skills.
And boards that can deliver according to the WSL judging criteria.
Matt Biolos has said he loves working with pros because it’s all about refinement. A few millimetres here and there. Things a pro can feel in a board and articulate that a non-pro would be oblivious to.
In all honesty lost /biolos is not scrubbing any boards at this point.
Prove me wrong, but the last time I walked by lost there was just a bunch of
Migrant workers plowing boards .
Who gives a .... when the waves are tiny and you just need something that will float and turn like Filipe did. This was proven back in the 70's. Full power to him I used to think he was a bit of wanker but have grown to like him. He knows how to surf small waves better than anybody else on tour and what equipment to use.
The funny thing about Toledo is that he's the most likely to jump on a twin or quad even though he's the fastest surfer on a thruster. Fuck knows what the other surfers are thinking.
You should have seen Gabe in waist high runners on a Cabianca yesterday morning. Don't know how he does it; he's no featherweight
More generous tail foil and less rocker.
I know you've ridden a Cabianca. Do you know what model he's on? Board looks so good
Not exactly sure what model- might be customs.
Will try and find out.
Always wanted to try one, and your old review added to that.
Cabianca DFK 2.0
Attempting to polish turds has become a full time job for the wsl and its team.
1ft raglan (4ft on the Craig scale) and the fake positivity in full swing.
Speaking of which 4-5 ft here on the forecast and its not even head height, called it 10ft yesterday and it was barely 4ft . Like the wsl swellnet surf reporters heed no feedback.
(A still shot of the wave of the day from the cam forthcoming no doubt )
Ha!
And on pro surfer boards.... most recreational surfers drive to the beach with multiple different boards. A pro surfer rides the same board at snapper as margs and now 1 ft NZ , how does that make sense and why do their shapers not know any better?
The shapers probably make more money off their small wave designs than their HPSBs and they get their pros to market those shapes by dropping clips ripping on them i.e.
or:
In an attempt to attract a main stream market that doesn't exist they've sanitized the shit out of pro surfing.
Get some 4 man heats happening and pull the plug on the priority rule all together. Then the punters won't be forced to watch countless un-ridden waves go by while 1 competitor politely sits back watching the opposition casually pick and chose what wave they want next.
Bring back the biff !!
Good call, no priority would stir things up and make it much more entertaining for viewers. 2 man heats are boring as fuck.
No such such thing in real life surfing, send them out to battle each other , best surfer wins rather than luckiest
That heat with lakey and carrissa hassling each other out of position trying to get priority is a perfect example
Agree
Even though they had priority best comp used to be four surfer Haleiwa. Especially if waves were good. Action non stop.
I always laugh at the ads for Apple's Siri - "Let me know if comp is on" - Should be "Let me know if someone actually catches a wave."
Just flip a coin before the heat to get rid of the priority nonsense that always waste time and waves. Solution simple.
Yes.......if its good enough for cricket
Caught the Jack/Kaoli heat and tuned in for the Zebrowski/Marks heat for the gorgeous sunset.
Sounds like I pretty much got the best of it.
"so often we see surfers unable to show their full potential. In what other sport does competition routinely bring out a worse version of an athlete?"
Maybe it's a generational thing with fear or lack of mental toughness when the pressure is on? Just watch any AFL match where million dollar forwards get jittery when lining up for an easy goal or kick around the corner when straight in front. No confidence.
So far the exuberant coverage and continuous aerial footage of glorious calm NZ ocean has got me really pumped!
(To go diving for kina).
There's been some great waves for you and your kneelo buddies out there.
You reckon Tya's overhyped FR? I see it more as a 15year old girl being thrust into the spotlight that is possibly overwhelming (plus her heat was in dogshit waves)....hard to beat Marks in those cons. But overhyped talentwise, i don't see it. I think she's got an ability that's untouched by any of the other women, just she isn't quite channeling it on the big stage yet....understandably given her age and the pressure she's probably feeling. Different on the CS where the spotlight is no where near what it is on the CT. Just my observations.
SR yes i agree i think shes just settling in .......
Talented but still too young. They should have made her wait a year. Had another go round on the challenged series like caity did.
Her heat was in excellent waves for the day (well maybe not excellent but wind had dropped and quite a few sets hitting around head high or so). I sat down to watch that live mainly to see how she went and if Caroline could go excellent but both were disappointing but Caroline got the job done. Tya tried to go straight up and down before making the section and got left behind on several set waves. She was quite good pre event but sadly way off yesterday. Maybe too young and certainly no experience in different waves
Cheers mate. Good to get word from the ground. And yep, pretty much what i reckon. Trying to grow from a teenager to a woman and being touted the next best thing has gotta have some negative psychological effects on a grom. I reckon that's partly to do with Erins poor form in the rashie too. Going from a grom to being recognised as someone who's expected to wipe the field, all the while transitioning into adulthood can't be a smooth transition. Can't imagine what it would be like when i was that age to have the world heaping expectations on you all while you're just trying to figure your place in the world out.
Which begs the question why are they there. Ban them until at least 18 and they grow up a bit. I heard Tya interviewed and she is well under the age to be doing them she was overwhelmed.
Transitioning to adulthood can take 40 to 50 years...
That moment you see the expanda foam next to the letterboxes at Bunnings and an evil mirth overcomes you...
Haha!
Couldn’t agree with you more. Wsl needs to stop hyping up these very young women as world title contenders. Or even letting them on tour so young. Also need a cut off for their events after the farce in Tahiti with the 12 year old. Tya would have been much better off doing a caity and turning down the place and spending time at home, working on her surfing and competing in all the junior events and another year of Q/CT events. No one should be on tour before they turn 16 or be eligible for a wildcard to a CT event. Even then I think full time on tour before 17 is too much. And I believe this even if they are surfing well! WSL need to stop hyping them and start putting some age limits in place. I know we are not tennis but they have put age limits on how many events women can play in a year.
What’s the modern day equivalent of mowing lawns for cash after being knocked off the tour with no education or qualifications? Selling courses and retreats on Instagram? MLM?
I see Tya as having beautiful technique for her age and if she can maintain her head space while coping with multiple losses as she develops she will be a holder of many world titles
As you have to learn to lose before you can learn how to win I hope she just rides it out and develops with time.
Best female coming through the ranks that I can see, even put coin on her to win a maiden title this year I am that confident in her ability
I honestly don't know what to think.
I tuned in last year a few times and it feels like I only saw her doing close-out reo's.
So far this year, I've seen all her heats and her wave reads look very ordinary- maybe too young, not experienced enough at different waves?
Feels like, apart from Snapper, we've barely seen her surf.
Hopefully we get more of a measure of her through the year because so far, it's been a real disappointment watching her surf.
Just watched the heat with Caz Marks yesterday.
2 fives in silky OH left point surf was a very underwhelming result.
Yeah that's a fair analysis. Seems the overhype comes more from the media towards her expected competitive success, but realistically, most rookies of any age tend to struggle with adjusting to the big league. And she absolutely rips, no doubt about that. Such a clean pure technique. Shades of Slater in her snap to slides. Not sure how she fares in the juice but wouldn't put too much expectation on that front yet. As for the Caz heat, they kept panning to her support crew (dad, coach) and everytime i see them, they look so serious and invested. Perhaps therein lies part of the problem. I reckon they shouldn't let kids compete so young. Can only have negative future side effects. Plus she's now living in the fictional world of 'pro surf' land, surrounded by the non reality of professional surfers all around her, the egos, the competitive beasts....again, can't be healthy, but will most likely sharpen her up over the next couple of years competetively, whether that's actually a good thing for her....
And I'd add to Tya that her board looked terrible for the conditions and she kept turning under the lip as it didn't carry enough to the lip and had no down the line speed. Looked like another who just used her gold coast board for raglan and expected it to work. Coach has a big role here too.
Am I seeing it wrong? Is ruling a world junior tour until you are 18 a bad thing these days?
I guess it must be. But as a father to only one daughter, I cannot fathom freeing my daughter at 13 or even 15yrs and allowing her to accept a trophy on a Corana pro podium from a drunkard.
I cannot see how that giving kids time to develop mentally and physically is such an unnecessary skill set to win world titles.
Great comment @remi
Agreed. It says a lot about the parents - both tyas and Erin’s that they are so invested. Contrast to caitys parents and her waiting at least a year to get started.
An Aussie example we love is ash Barty. Huge success early. Quit at16/17 as pressure already too much. Took a couple of years off to grow up and have some time at home. Came back a bit more mature and absolutely smashed it. I’m happy with a 17/18 age limit.
I think Raglan has shown itself to be a swell magnet (compared to the dire look of the weather maps) and moving the comp to later in the year might find a very reliable destination. Month of May obviously not the best time with threats of sub-tropical lows.
Or earlier :-)
They've just been desperately unlucky.
Yep, if you could pick any month I'd pick April.
But May would be a close 2nd.
If only they had the flexibility to start on the practice day.
There is a low forming under tassy Tues night/Wed morning that surely looks like it'll send something up the tasman. Consistent 35-40knots and gusting over 50.
It sits in the 'tassy/bottom of south island swell window' for ~24hrs and normally it'd take ~3 days for any swell generated to arrive so they should get waves before the window closes on Sat 23rd/Sun 24th which is still within the waiting period (which closes Mon 25th).
Wind next w/e is east-northeast which isn't great but it's not north or northwest.
I can see why they're keen to get heats done before then but I'm picking more waves to arrive before the end.
Yeah i'm seeing the same maps muzzled. Looks like swell incoming to me on the weekend
But will the low in the tasman above it sending swell north to south cancel that swell out?
Na don't worry about that low. Looks like waves for Saturday and Sunday to me
Of the footage Jordy filmed, how much made it into the clip?
10%? Less..?
Can't edit the bad stuff out in comps unfortunately.
I'd say a very high %-age.
Can't see Jordy wasting too many waves at pumping Iluka or Angas.
Nah, 10% might be over the top but a good day of filming would only see a fraction kept.
Back in the day, yeah, or for longer form stuff.
Nowadays with You-tube channels needing content, it's much more WYSIWYG.
That looks like a single session at I..a and maybe 2 at Angas on the way through.
Doubt many waves he rode those sessions ended up being binned- especially with Jordy not going for airs.
You can see the strike rate of, say Ethan Ewing, at Periscope's for that SITD.
Most waves are usable.
Can't wait to see you at the wall. Thanks for spelling it out for those who didn't already know. Fuck you are a wanker.
hahahaha
Bet he was in the wannasurf comments sections back in the day.
Point taken but he didn't exactly try and hide where he was.
Location hidden again mate.
Mate I’m from Vicco and knew where it was from the video. It’s hardly a secret. You think people are gunna see this and go “Jordie was ripping “x”, I’m gonna head there”. Maybe have a nice cup of tea.
Haha. Perfect.
Everybody and his dog know those spots. It ceased being a secret about 1975.
and then every non-surfer after Nat's bruised melon popped up on all the nightly news shows and every paper.
"secret spot"
Oh the WALL!! I was wondering where that was!!
hahah, classic. you'd get a job in a second with seXplore, boldly going where people have gone before. To meet the grand Calhoun, go to any Holland Village eatery and ask for the face-like-a-smashed-crab. He will come to you.
Honestly why do the pros even employ a coach.....and if you need advice hook up with a local shredder.......and its amazing that time after time the pros are caught short on the proper equipment....why ? both those questions have been touched on by others above but its incomprehensible that they haven't got a full tool kit......and it would make the surfing more interesting to watch in mediocre conditions because surfers would be drawing slightly different lines to each other, a bit like the old days where everyone rode something a bit different...
Don't get me started about surf coaches.
Because at the end of the day they're not particularly bright?
The surfers employing these morons and the morons themselves.
I’m generally perplexed at the need for coaches/fluffers/hanger onerers……
………I started thinking about why they ‘need’ them? I’m clearly not anywhere near the tour or that level but have spent a life staring at, experiencing and experimenting in the ocean to give myself the confidence to make decisions.
I wonder if the average young pro ‘needs’ this help as they’ve rarely had to really work out anything out for themselves? Maybe they’ve been so insulated by overbearing parents and the scene that travelling on your own, even to places you’ve surfed many, many times before seems too difficult?
I imagine it’s mostly a psychological crutch and hand holding. In the case of elites like John and Ross maybe more technical breakdown of clips etc.
Anyone else have thoughts for the affirmative or negative?
When you sign this contract, I will become your coach and this man will be your fluffer.
I've said it a dozen times, but I reckon it is just a simple arms race thing.. without any coaches you'd get the black dog occasionally:
"why are the brazzo bros giggling at me? did the head judge get cross yesty arvo when I got the last avocado nori roll? is that 2%er flirting with me or screwing with me? Did I come across cunty in the post heat interview? That prio call was wrong, right? I snaked that local and now local tiktokers hate me.."
dunno.. it is just someone in your corner away from home.
if a few of your competitors get coaches chumming about the place schmoozing between those social circles, and having the hot gossip and able to assure those competitors all is cool and they just need to surf well in this shit-slop, you'd need one too.
I even think sharing a coach would be good in that context. 'coach' isn't the right word, but anything more accurate sounds a bit fuken special dunnit?
anything more accurate sounds a bit fuken special dunnit?
hahahha, brilliant!
I traveled like this for elite sports for a while. It’s pretty lonely. The athletes are young. They are on the road for months at a time. Have someone there that helps you with your head space/planning is so helpful. Help you review what went wrong. Have experience with a lot of these waves (very helpful early on). And also locations. Where to eat/stay. Who has good local knowledge. Some coaches guide your physical training. Some have groups of surfers they look after and this can become your tour family where you support one another/stay together (like dog marsh or leandros crew). Lulu mentioned leandro cooking for them and helping out in other ways. Much less lonely like that. Especially if you are not travelling your family anymore, or even then. If you have been on tour for a while and know the stops and can afford to have someone travel with you then a local coach is a great idea. Although at a new wave like raglan they could all have used some local knowledge
Happens to the best.
Medina in a quciksilver westuit!
He's sponsored by quiksilver? Or doesn't have a wesdtuit sponsor?
My favourite clip from raglan thus far.
Amazing grace.
In summation: Pro surfing isn't pro.
hahaha
Outstanding
Choice.
Sweet as.
How good was day 3 though? One heat to test the brothers sense of humour. Poor renato looked like he had a bad day in the VB post heat interview. Wish they had caught up with Crosby as he looked like he was up for a chat. As per the discussion about boards I find it ironic because when KS was trying different equipment he got bagged by nearly everyone including the judges. Maybe they will get lucky if they try Raglan again next year or add this location also. ps one of the spots in the Jordy clip was as crowded as I've seen it this long weekend. Coincidence?
if there are no coaches, who is the broadcast going to cut to in between sets?
Good read thanks. Particularly liked the lawn mowing line.
I'm bummed about this contest cos Raglan has always been a place I want to go. Such a picturesque lineup and seems like a relatively uncrowded place. I don't know what the situation is on the ground so I'm probably wrong about the vibe.
I imagine there will be an influx of travelling surfers after this, particularly competitively-minded South Americans, making it less mellow in the future than it ever was.
It's uncrowded relative to the super bank. I surfed there for three years while at uni in the eighties, and I mostly surfed indicators and whale bay because I thought Manu was too crowded!
There's been an influx of travelling surfers for years here especially south Americans and euros. Mostly lowish ability level. Not sure it will change much
Ban South Americans and Bay of Plenty'ans, and the points would be pretty serene
Why BP surfers?
Every time there's a large/perfect swell in Raglan, they invade us. Fair enough, as they get so many flat days, and it's only 2 hours here.
It was mostly a joke, though. There's a healthy rivalry between BOP and Rags.
Haha got ya. Sounds like a less serious version of GC surfers heading to the Northern rivers and Clarence zones
Loved the write up Steve. Paradox 2 especially. It’s ridiculous hearing people talking about what a radical choice of board it was given that at many breaks these days it’s the most big standard board in the water. Between that and the relentless positivity in dogshit conditions it made me turn it off and actually do my work for a change. I’m not sure that lots of people buying t-shirts is all that interesting, and arguably isn’t something we should be expected to celebrate.
Thinking about this commerce stuff that's come up and how the WSL is spruiking their economic impact during the broadcast, it reminded me of when I used to listen to Dan Prodan's WSL podcast (note to the cool kids, I said used to listen...I don't anymore). He would say that the WSL is a media company that owns a sporting event. Or something like that.
It makes me think of this video I saw yesterday on the ABC about the Enhanced Games. You know that alternative to the Olympics where athletes can take steroids and whatnot to see how far the human body can go? Former Australian Olympian, James Magnusson signed on, among others.
It turns out it's just a company that wants to sell peptides and services to help every day punters to get on the gear "safely". Nothing about sport at all, the Games are just the mechanism to promote that business.
So as I wake up to the reality of new age marketing and sport, I'm starting to realise that the WSL isn't a sporting event for our sake or surfing's sake. Like everything else in the world, they're just a corporate entity with something to sell. And at the moment they've decided they're selling economic activity in far flung parts of the world.
Think Caity may have been thinking the same, and that might explain, as b6 noted in the live comments, why she was afflicted with a case of the Geoff Haywards. That or she’s scheduled for an hour plus with Dave and Dan Prodan next week, and the prospect was just too much for her.
One of my mates was saying to me a few years back how he wants a free for all games with athletes jacked up on whatever they want.
I asked him - at what age would you like your children to start doping?
For some reason the appeal of the idea dropped immediately.
Cheers Steve, so enjoyable I read twice.
Not sure about the subheading: ‘Manu Bay pumped early and pumped late’.
As for getting them into good waves. Is there no one on tour who has year 9 level maths and statistics that realise being skunked will happen much more often than not given the parameters they give themselves.
They run 58 heats which at 35 mins per heat takes 34 hours give or take (not including bonsoy brew breaks). So best part of 4 days. They are turning up to a zone for 2.7% of the year. Granted months where they have a greater chance of decent waves.
If you were a betting man there’s no way with the above you’d ever put a decent bet on them scoring good waves for the majority of a comp. They are almost guaranteeing themselves to fail every time…….and going by the most talked about topics to do with the Woz it is generally of the ‘should a been here yesterday’ or similar.
The Woz is like a one legged man in an arse kicking comp.
Excellent thought soli. That would be a really great analysis to estimate the probably of contest quality surf given the historical swell and wind data during a given window.
Since it's now tourism funded, they've got less control but it would be handy if they could argue for longer waiting periods when a place like WA govt funds a contest outside the optimal season.
The whole Coach thing as stated above is a joke.
FFS itsSurfing 101.
Watch the ocean for a while, observe where the sets break, where the wide ones peak and where the double ups go, size up a take off where you can paddle to reach the wide ones or the double ups, Once out there watch the white wash trail or notice where the builds let you chip in, triangulate your position and bobs your uncle.
Even use your Apple watch to time the sets and superior fitness from all the gym work to stroke into the waves you want.
Forget priority take off in the makable section.
Seems the best waves this season have been caught under priority.
It’s surfing. The WSL went to G-Land in 2022. It was underwhelming. I bet it lost money.
For those disappointed that it isn’t the dream tour, they do have Teahupoo, Cloudbreak and Pipeline which isn’t bad.
There is no pro surfing model where it makes a consistent profit and it costs a motza. Just about everything has been tried over the decades of surfing comps.
I seem to remember Bruce Raymond saying it cost Quiksilver about $2.5 million dollars to put on the Snapper Rocks event in about 2005. Who knows how much an event costs in 2026? The prize money alone for the New Zealand Pro is over 1 million dollars. Let’s say, ballpark, $4 million dollars plus per event.
I don’t think they are making too much money from viewer eyeballs as shown by the empty advertisement spaces. No wonder they want govt tourism money to run an event probably just to reduce the bleeding.
Enjoy the comps while they last. Thanks Dirk Ziff.
Good to see Glen Winton getting a mention in the writeup. I remember him riding his quads at Norah Head and being in awe of him. From memory the base of the fins were at least half the base length of a normal thruster fin, they were super flexible too, you could hear them whistle as he rode past. Pro surfers back then were willing to experiment & is what made surfing interesting.
Toledos fins looked disk sanded... flex fins are fun....when its smaller.
Great WSL wrap and angles Steve, thanks again for your sharp pen.
I am wondering wether jet bottom channels by Earle Pederson and Murray Bourton may be the answer?
if Toledo's nickname isn't Wombat round these parts from here on in then i'm unsubscribing.
Watching this comp objectively, i can't help but think the WSL is idealising a pretty toxic culture. Pro surfers in general seem to be overall seem sit in a pretty egocentric place, it's all about 'me the champ'. Yep, that's sport,, but is that surfing? I think not. That's why i have respect for surfers like Lobby and Simmers, Miguel, who still maintain the surfers surfer persona amongst the backslappers, hanger onerers, and the general bullshit that goes with being a sponsored surfer with an audience on instagram. Just all seems a whole lot of pointing this pursuit we all love in the absolutely wrong direction to why we all love it
That’s happened forever though hasn’t it, look at all those Kauai mongaloids like Kala and Kaiborg when Andy was at his peak. His feet hardly touched the ground they carried him around on their shoulders so much
But yeah I agree.
when will pro-surfing get another hero-at-the-top who champions waves-as-stars like we want (if surfing is indeed to be a sport), instead of starring 'sports-champs' in 'waves' like they want us to want
there is no impending support from non-core surfers coming to open their wallets and get excited other than for weekend craft-beers. It is sooooo barely a sport. especially if the waves are not the stars. up-and-coming helicoptered groms from the well-to-do included. this is it. Is anyone coming to save it? kelly?
Caity, if she gets to be herself?
man, if that little home-schooled legend was looking back at the circus and thinking serious, constructive thoughts that whole heat, I would whoop and holler and slap the bathwater like the guy when Truman left the dome in a heartbeat.
:)
Yep. Shit humans covered in stickers. Seems the lesser known ones are the worst of the lot. All ego. The fact half these fuckers can't read a basic pointbreak lineup as stated above is a classic case in point. They're not ocean people as you and i know surfing.
yep! haha. And make sure you only reply to insta comments with emojis and not any thought....cos that's the epitome of being cooooool. Don't be human with thoughts and feelings heaven forbid. Bunch of fucken wankers propped up by instagram, stickers and the woz beast.
It's pretty depressing and that's kind of where I was going in my post above. The WSL is now selling economic activity to states and councils around the world.
Fund us to run a comp and we'll put eyeballs on your region and spruik it for 10 days to boost your tourism. Surfing is just the vehicle for that and our attention is the product.
Maybe that's too cynical
Nup. You're spot on. Margs is a prime example of how to put the spotlight on a region and completely fuck it. Margon Bay.
Some will say growth is good. Fk those people.
Agree
Trouble is, I like watching good surfing and I love sport so I'm basically hooked.
"Watching this comp objectively, i can't help but think the WSL is idealising a pretty toxic culture."
tbf they have yet to set dwarves on fire like some other sports
Not sure, for the general good, whether this character should ever again be allowed to breach the boundaries of Fitzroy. Keep him in there and have him as a permanent exhibit. As a post modern representation of himself. Is that how people in Fitzroy talk? Not that I’d ever wanna go anywhere Gertrude St. But would kinda love to see Frenchy caricature Lucas Lecacheur in the next SITD, up against DHD and JS, with Morgs as the test pilot. There’d be some cracking banter, no doubt, talking shop. Maybe Fil will continue his surprise tilt towards the experimental avant-garde and unveil the Brutalist model for round three. Joe Starling can inform us of the great relationship Fil has with Lucas, of course. Lucas might make a good coach too. Wonder what his theory on leg power to volume density ratio is, and how he makes subtle adjustments to rocker?
https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2026/may/17/surfers-say-that-b…
Wowee! Those are out there..........functional too he reckons.....
I'm dumb and don't know shit. But...since Pyzel Ghost etc etc, aren't all the pro boards sorta fishy/hybridy/grovelery? They're fish with tail rocker. Except the boards they use in real serious stuff, the longer thumb tails. I suspect the pros have small wave boards in their quiver with as much foam as they're willing to work with...which is maybe the problem, but at some point you have too much foam and lose the rail? I think? You can get a lot of foam into something that looks like a normal modern shortboard.
vahine gets screwed again.
no way Molly beat her, not even close.
the pro surfing charade continues while the lemmings march on
Jack had a rude awakening when he first visited. Boards looked awful, and his surfing too.
Here's his Rags quiver. Note the "twinnie, hahahaha" comment. It's still taboo.
It’s certainly interesting to me that the pros apart from Toledo have been apprehensive about using a”non standard “ pro board. It’s like they are all sheep, too scared to surf something that would make the sections that a lot of them are getting caught behind in.
Any chance to get an upper hand surely includes equipment not just being supremely fit. So what if the board volume is above 30litres.
One of my mates had a chat to Jason S the other day and re reckoned most of the JS riders were on a monsta outline with a Xero gravity bottom curve after their visit earlier this year to gain some more speed. Seemed to work for both JR and KV as that heat could have gone either way. So a flatter rocketed Monsta
No Leashbar
The sad thing is that the beachbreaks love these conditions. Would have been nice to have the flexibility to hold a day or two of the event there, either at Ruapuke or Ngarunui. That said, it's usually stupidly consistent at this time of the year on the points, so they probably didn't even think it was worth factoring the beachies in .
All true and good points (mwahahaha!), but having seen the amount of infrastructure they've got at Manu - it's practically a village - I wonder how they would do a mobile day. Ruas is out, I reckon, with the windy road, even going east of the mountain.
Indeed. Griff and Rio trying out 2+1s.
Even on the 'flat' days, and even if you're a big fella. Cole H this morning
And just a few comments re alt boards and Raglan.
9 out of 10 days a normal shortboard or a step up - both without excessive rocker - is the way to go. Waves may be flatter than Kirra and Snapper, but they have deep water power, especially the outer points.
Something that glides well, holds a rail, and handles going bloody fast, is the right board.
Proper Ledge, and you'll want some rocker. Small'ish and fast, a good twinnie is fun.
IB, what about when the devil wind blows? Couple of those heats looked pretty choppy and I wonder if the twin/quad performance may be limited by the chop.
Devil wind I go elsewhere. Hate it, and I'm useless at dealing with it.
If it's not too awful, I'll ride a bigger chop busting board, a la 6'10 DS
Maybe that’s why the pro’s have stuck with the thrusters. Noted though that some of the heats were in pretty clean conditions when a quad would have been fine.
If anyone's tempted, despite the lacklustre conditions recently, here's a piece of land for sale
https://lodge.co.nz/buy/properties-for-sale/listing/LC21853?utm_source=…
Gees you'd quickly learn which is the devil wind if you owned that property.
very true. but we've been through this before and we arrive back at the same place 30 years later.
Rabbit B initiated the best surfers, best waves philosophy with the billabong challenge in the 90's, which i understand set the template that was introduced to the WSL not along after.
here we are again 30 years later in 2026: not the best surfers the last few years and definitely not the best waves.
Rabbit, youre a legend. if youre not exhausted, can you please push your philosophy again ?
Big fan of your writing Steve, but...
A lot of sports, Formula One and golf, to name two off the top of my head, justify much of their existence by this ability to trickle down improvements to the common vehicle or golfer respectively.
Actually, despite all the marketing hype, the rules of golf strictly forbid any kind of meaningful performance improvement in equipment, lest the courses become redundant. The courses only exist cause the land was purchased for peanuts waaay back in the day.
Similarly, F1 has strict rules against making them faster (they are already crazy fast). More fuel efficient yes, faster no as the cars over-power all but the newest tracks.
But i think those observations support your argument about pro surfing doggedly sticking to a design that doesn't serve the general public.
I'd have to gently argue that point based on what my Dad (fanatic golfer) has told me (and backed up by research).
Yes, there were rollback provisions to protect the integrity of existing courses but the improvements in balls, irons and woods in terms of materials, adjustability and forgiveness are all very real and driven by the pro tour.
Likewise, F1 may have rules against making them faster but innovations like regenerative braking, suspension improvements, materials have all bled into consumer vehicles.
Use sailing, tennis, fishing etc etc- improvements at the elite level have all bled down the chain.
I reckon most of the golf club improvements have been to widen the sweet spot to make the ball easier to keep straight for average golfers with dodgy swings. Making golf easier for desperate weekend hackers is where the money is. There’s millions of them.
And there you have it.
“But, I guess, we didn’t really want to do a twinny on tour.”